How abortion bans make inequality worse

441,230
0
2022-07-08に共有
And the study that offers a glimpse into a post-Roe v. Wade future.

Subscribe and turn on notifications 🔔 so you don't miss any videos: goo.gl/0bsAjO

In 2008, researchers with the University of California San Francisco embarked on a study that compared the outcomes of two similar groups of women, each at a crucial juncture in their lives: a visit to an abortion clinic. The groups differed, though, in whether or not they were able to terminate an unwanted pregnancy. It was called the Turnaway Study, named for those who were turned away by the clinic because their pregnancies were past legal gestational limits, and it provides some of the best data we have on the impacts of abortion bans.

Among the study’s findings is the severe financial impact of being forced to parent a new child when someone is already living in difficult financial circumstances. People who seek abortions, especially later-term abortions, are far more likely than the general population to be living in poverty, or otherwise financially unstable. That fact makes it unsurprising that, when researchers asked women about their reasons for seeking an abortion, not being financially prepared was the most common reason. This video offers a glimpse into the financial penalty of parenting under difficult circumstances.

We interviewed several women who had similar experiences to the women in the study. We didn’t seek out interviewees who exactly reflected the circumstances of the study participants (i.e., the length of gestation when they sought an abortion, or their socioeconomic background) but their stories reveal some parallels: most people want an abortion because they don’t feel financially stable or don’t have a partner they want to co-parent with.

The Turnaway Study also looked at mental health outcomes, relationship outcomes, and whether or not study participants chose adoption instead of parenting. Whether or not they chose adoption is relevant to common pro-life rhetoric, which encourages people to give unwanted children up for adoption rather than choose abortion. But the Turnaway Study found that 91% of women who were denied an abortion chose to parent, which indicates that adoption is not a feasible alternative for most people. We interviewed Gretchen Sisson, a researcher who looked at adoption rates and motivations among the Turnaway Study participants.

For more coverage of the Turnaway Study:
www.nytimes.com/2013/06/16/magazine/study-women-de…

For lead Turnaway Study researcher Diana Greene Foster’s book about her study:
bookshop.org/books/the-turnaway-study-ten-years-a-…

For links to further research using Turnaway Study data:
www.ansirh.org/sites/default/files/publications/fi…

For Gretchen Sisson’s work on adoption:
www.whijournal.com/article/S1049-3867(16)30348-6/f…

We also interviewed Katie Woodruff, who analyzed news coverage of abortion:
pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30309695/

Make sure you never miss behind the scenes content in the Vox Video newsletter, sign up here: vox.com/video-newsletter

Vox.com is a news website that helps you cut through the noise and understand what's really driving the events in the headlines. Check out www.vox.com/

Support Vox's reporting with a one-time or recurring contribution: vox.com/contribute-now

Shop the Vox merch store: vox.com/store

Watch our full video catalog: goo.gl/IZONyE

Follow Vox on Facebook: facebook.com/vox
Follow Vox on Twitter: twitter.com/voxdotcom
Follow Vox on TikTok: tiktok.com/@voxdotcom

コメント (21)
  • @Vox
    Thanks for watching. To read more of our ongoing coverage on what the end of the federally guaranteed right to abortion means for the United States, catch up on our articles here: bit.ly/3bMm7sg
  • If you want to stop abortions, don't start by making them illegal. Start by fixing the problems that lead to abortions: poverty, insufficient childcare resources, etc. It feels like we care more about the unborn child than the living child and parent.
  • @ziqi92
    All of this doesn’t even begin to mention necessary abortions for miscarriages. My mom was pregnant again when I was 9, but that pregnancy just straight up failed. Fetus had died for unknown reasons after 4 months. My mom had to get an abortion in order to remove it. Complete abortion bans would have ruined her health.
  • As someone who is currently looking for an apartment with my 2 month old son, it’s not easy to do child rearing. I never wanted an abortion. But you quickly realize how the society is not prepared for children. Edit: ad hominem is an argumentative fallacy used to attack an individual instead of the argument. The fact that individuals assume my life based on a few words I commented on a YouTube video, is jarring and that’s why issues like these are still talked about!
  • If you look back at history a pattern shows up: if you ban something that everybody wants, it instead becomes unsafe and unregulated (Ex: prohibition. Instead of stopping people from drinking, they just started making their own drinks, and there was no longer any kind of minimum drinking age.). An abortion ban would have a similar effect. Illegal imports, unsafe methods of abortion, etc.
  • @nickc3657
    All this in a country without guaranteed healthcare or paid parental leave.
  • "If someone tells you they're not ready to carry a pregnancy to term, they're not. Believe them." This made me so emotional. I wasn't ready. I knew that. I was so, so lucky to be believed, and to receive abortion care. I can tell you with absolute certainty that my outcomes were better because I received that care.
  • @elizaiv
    This only comes to show that abortion is not just a pro-life or pro-choice matter, because the consequences of a pregnancy don't simply end by giving birth, and that's particularly valid in countries without strong social system. It's a matter of taking responsibility, having the resources (incl. financial) and being able to commit long-term - so many things men can easily escape by simply leaving. I just cannot understand how decision makers in the politics/judicial system don't see that.
  • @Sonydev19
    Making childcare accessible and free is important, secondly allow women to take more parental leave , childcare leave with pay. Raising a child is no joke, harder if you are a single parent.
  • @lralou8
    Something this also highlighted is how fathers are not held to the same standard as mothers. And how the system set up in our country don’t hold fathers accountable. The mother is de facto parent. And that happens regardless. As somebody who divorced my son’s father, and he was planned, I am still dealing with a father who is not present and not financially supportive.
  • @emexdizzy
    It's almost like if we don't make sure people can afford to be parents, they they try to avoid becoming parents. Who'd'a thunk? IDK, maybe if we want fewer abortions, we should have extensive support systems like universal healthcare, free childcare, paid parental leave, et cetera.
  • Forcing people to go against their wishes, whether to keep a child or abort a child, causes so much trauma. That’s why not giving people the ability to choose really shackles their lives.
  • the people who made these laws have never been impoverished. never been without food, electricity, or a roof over their head. just give them to foster care!!! like are you so detached from reality that u think being abused/r*ped in the system until u age out is beneficial to anyone??? 1 in 3 homeless ppl in AZ are children who aged out of the system
  • Just wanted to mention that not all abortions are because of unwanted pregnancies
  • as in the book Freakonomics, Steven D Levitt says that when crime was peaking in 70's and 80's in the USA and suddenly dropped in the early 90's and people suddenly grappling for explanations. Many were floated around. Better policing, stricter punishment for criminals, a growing economy and a myriad of other reasons. But the true reason was the Roe v Wade decision in 73 that made abortions legal for all in the USA. This led to women of colour, of poor economic background, material abusers and all others who had unwanted or unplanned pregnancies get an abortion. But before that, they had to have a child. And that child was more likely to become a criminal because of the mother's background and subsequent parenting. hence crime was in a growth. but by late 80's, the children who would have been born if abortion wasn't legalized would be in their late teens. An age where they would be at their criminal peak committing violent crimes. This led to low criminal population in all. hence the drop in crime rates. Its true that overturning Roe v Wade sent USA by 50 years. But in 20 years, if it isnt overturned back again, we will see higher crimes and more violent crimes.
  • Things i didnt even think about until this video: 1) Mourning a life and a career without the responsibility and burden of an unwanted pregnancy/child. 2) Being able to leave a relationship without having to consider a child/family being impacted
  • i think a huge factor in this is that fathers aren’t held accountable. it takes two to have a child. and as a man, i’m disappointed with the amount of men that don’t step up and take care of their own child. it’s cowardly and should be punished.
  • @Zibonnn
    Fix your healthcare, America. Many of these people won't even seek abortion anymore. The medical expenses in the US are a joke to humanity!
  • Everyone needs to come to terms with the fact that people who are pro-forced birth just don't care. They know the realities of the struggles these women will have to experience and they don't care. They know that this will lead to more people being stuck in poverty, they just don't care. You cannot reason with these people, no new information will matter, they have the information and they still just don't care.