Is Affirmative Action Fair?

A few words about Above the Noise comments section: We welcome your constructive criticism and your disagreements with our content. We especially love it if you cite real, peer-reviewed research or personal experiences to back up your critiques. What we DO NOT welcome are hateful, offensive or otherwise harmful comments directed at individuals or groups of people. If you leave a comment that aims only to stir up pain or insult, and is not about a respectful exchange of ideas, we will delete your comment and block you. Luckily, this only happens rarely on our channel -- but we want to be clear about our policy. Thanks for watching!

Race shouldn't be a factor in anything

when you are considering race for an applicant, you are practicing racism .

Should race be a factor? Short answer: a giant NO. You failed to mention that Asians are a minority too. Giving the best students a handicap based on race is not "reverse discrimination", it's flat out racism! You said "diverse teams are better". I find it extremely sad and demening that what you think makes people "different" is skin colour. I'll tell you what's true diversity: diversity of thought! No one cares about your looks as long as you bring interesting ideas to the table. You're risking excluding the best Asian and white minds just to take in people who look different in your pathetic definition of difference. This is unfair to those who get excluded and patronizing for minorities. If you wish to help poor people give them financial help, just like any other country. If blacks struggle, help them! Give them the chance to compete. Think of a better scholarship system, so you can get brilliant minds to Universities. Don't sacrifice merit on the altar of equality. You can help people in need while being fair to everyone else.

Man I’m Latino. and if a asian or white guy get better grades than me, They should be chosen. Not me, because of some law against racism/... We should choose based on merite!

I’m Hispanic, and I’d personally much rather be chosen because of my hard work rather than how I was born.

improving early education seems like a much better idea to me.

MLK said we should not judge people by their color of their skin but by the content of their character

I’m Asian and, no offense, I hate affirmative action. We need to vote a president who will destroy AA .

this reminds me of the Indian dude who pretended to be black to get into med school with 3.1 GPA

They should do away with affirmative action and instead throw more money towards lower-income education and neighborhoods. This will pretty much fix all those problems because if everyone is learning nearly the same curriculum without any extra “noise” from their surroundings then everyone will have a MORE equal chance than now.

Make admissions anonymous.

Gotta love fighting racism with racism

Nope. It should always be the most qualified applicants, regardless of race.

how is this even a question..

We tried this in India with caste and trust me don't try this at home.

Race and gender should not be considered. If they are the other side is discriminated against. The class point has merit but the best way is to start much earlier and give everyone the same leg up or opportunities.

What's the word for when you choose someone over someone else, because of the colour of their skin?

Why do people have stronger feelings about affirmative action than legacy admissions? There are more legacy admits that don’t meet the grades+test score rigor than black or Hispanic students, but you hardly hear this topic in the comments.

I agree 100% that race should NEVER be a factor in anything. I would argue colleges shouldn't even be able to see your name until you attend, since they could tell from that alone. If something is outside of your control, it shouldn't be asked on college admissions.