French Onion Soup from 1651

Thanks Bright Cellars for sponsoring this video and for the limited-time offer! Go to brightcellars.com/tastinghistory to get 10% off my bundle.

I appreciate how, unlike many recipes, you don't pretend that onions can be caramelized in 15 minutes or something ridiculous. That takes time, dang it!

To see where this channel started to where you're at now, Max, is absolutely astonishing and so well deserved.

I made this tonight--it's delicious! As a historical reenactor I learn through doing, and I can definitely see why this would be popular: easy, simple easy to find ingredients, and makes do with stale bread. I love this channel--it neatly falls into the middle part of a Venn diagram of our love of history, food, and Pokemon.

Man, your linguistic skills are absolutely impressive. I know this channel is about food but I can’t help but notice how precise and eloquent you speak in every language, English, French, Italian. It’s kind of crazy and almost seems a little super natural the way you can just switch like that and almost sound like a native speaker of the selected language 😆 great job 👍

"Mind your onions" made me think of a story I was told by the headmistress of my elementary school many many years ago. She was one of those people who seemed to have had a very rich life and as a result always had an abundance of stories to tell. We all adored her at school as well so she always had a willing audience. Anyway, so in this particular story, she was living in New York in the US (she's Swedish) with a dear friend of hers. Apparently, they were living in a semi-rough neighborhood at the time and her friend had been ambushed by a robber on her way home from the supermarket. Carrying two large grocery bags in her arms, she did what any normal person would do in such a moment of panic and shouted in a strong Skåne-accent (it's a very strong dialect from the south of Sweden) "Röööör inte mina potäter!!!" ("Don't touch my potatoes!"). The robber was obviously confused and caught completely off-guard by her actions, most likely having no idea what in the world this crazy woman was screaming so he left without taking anything. It must have been almost 30 years now since I first heard that story and it's still one of my all-time favorites. Mind your onions and don't touch my potatoes. Update: thank you for the likes and comments, everyone! I’m happy that Margareta’s story could bring a smile (and some laughs) to so many people. I’m sure she would be happy to know that her stories are still enjoyed even today as well. I don’t for a second miss school, but I really miss her stories. She was an amazing storyteller and just an all-around lovely person.

Max's little smile after the first bite says it all. It's always the first-taste smile that makes these videos perfect.

I wonder if the tale of Stanislaw Leszcynski about onion soup is actually that he popularized a certain type of recipe (like the stock based soup vs the milk based), which might have been a step in the gradual development of our modern version. It is a fact that hosts of the period tried to outdo each other in serving unusual foods or having amazing entertainment, much as people do today. He might have actually gotten the recipe by watching someone make it and taking notes, then passed the instructions on to his own cook. Maybe the aristocrat had a hugely successful dinner featuring his favorite version of the recipe and it caught on. That sounds plausible to me. Much more so than the king fixing his own soup.

I made a long-forgotten onion dish I found in a book from 1667. It was apparently known in the 1300s as "Lady's Palfrey' and described then as "An Tyckke stewe of onyen rightly boilèd and none speedily groyned and gadrooked by nymberèd hyrbs dishèd in ye bodrundrum pot." The C17th recipe was similar and tasted more or less like eating raw onion despite being boiled in sherry for 10 hours. The person who wrote down the recipe added a poem: Hebe's Lament, or, The Disparaged Maiden "I long to suckle on thy milk, O spicy tumour of the earth, fair trollop of the tillage realm, who can esteem thy fragrant worth?" It went on for 8 pages but with no cooking instructions.

I love how the bowl shrank but the slice of baguette is consistent when this soup evolved over the centuries.

Max has decided to be as French as Onion Soup. I love It! Also, nice to see us return to a milk soup recipe again.

I love the vibe of Max's videos they're like an old pbs show so good.

What I really love is that you're still making videos of foods that will be in your cookbook; you're not hoarding them as a selling point- you're SHARING them as a selling point; so instead of a huge discovery of new recipes, it's like a sing-along for cooking. Though I have to say, it would be really cool when you mention new vs. Old recipes, if you made both and compared their flavor profiles for anyone who hasn't had that food before, or just to highlight differences in how the human palate has changed. So excited for your book release, and we're all so proud of how far this journey has taken you, and how much farther you can go- the sky's the limit!

In Hungary it is somewhat customary to serve french onion soup in a round bread loaf, and the other detail I noticed is that my own mother also creates this dish with milk!

My grandmother got stuck in Paris in 1940 (we all know what happened then, right?). A little Irish woman with a bad attitude would obviously stick out like a sore thumb, so she hid in a restaurant for most of the time she was there. She learned a LOT of recipes, not all of them French and brought them home with her. THIS WAS ONE OF THEM. I'm thrilled that you did this. I've learned a LOT watching your videos. Thank you for this. A lot of memories for me in that bowl. :) -Vic

I just got my copy of Tasting History and I love the way it's laid out. It feels like I'm reading a history book instead of just a cookbook, with historical images and sources for where the recipe came from (including a bunch of info about the recipe's history. Just like the simulations!). All the recipes (except for the spartan black broth) look like ones I would actually like to try out. The french onion soup is super good.

My wife bought me your cookbook and when she realized this was in it, she got super excited. Modern french onion soup is one of her specialties.

As a French person born in Paris and who has eaten countless onion soups at home and in restaurants, I can't tell you how happy this video makes me! Hearing you speak French must be my favorite thing in the whole world right now.

😂🤣😂🤣 French onion soup always reminds me of a hilarious family story. When my dad was a teen, he and his best friend and their girlfriends went to the local drive-in. They had q very diverse restaurant and onion soup was one of those choices. My dad got the soup. Well it caused a hideous case of gas, but of course he didn't want to pass gas when he was on a hot date, so for two hours he held it in. His friend was driving, they dropped off their dates. Then dad let it rip. It was so bad his friend pulled the car over and threw up. You might be curious as to what movie was playing.....I kid you not...it was "Gone With the Wind!" 😂😂

Interesting how "a lot of things together" also reflected in music: with polyphony constantly hitting the top of the charts. Then changing to the exposure of a single melody (ingredient) with the backup of the rythm section/basso continuo (complementary accompaniment).