Mafia 3 kinda sucks...

I encountered every bug you talked about, especially the black screen one was the worst

Mafia III made the mistake of being an easily digestible free roam game in a game series that was not an easily digestible free roam game series. It’s mediocre on its own, and horrible compared to Mafia 1 and Mafia 2

I really enjoyed mafia 3 because i'm a punisher fan

Man, I thought Mafia 3 would play out in the same formula as the first two games the first time I played it. It was just so repetitive with what you had to do to progress the story. The setting of the game was nice and all. But other than that, it was just so disappointing.

I’m currently playing this and the one thing that most bothers me is the lack of an ACTUAL garage. For such a car centric game it’s weird to me that you can’t keep cars you steal. Don’t get me wrong, I enjoy some of the cars in the preset menu but imo there’s realllly not much variety. There are some of the most iconic styled cars on the street. I WANT TO KEEP THEM! Not all of them, like in mafia 2 there was a garage limit which would be FINE for this game too. If there is a way to keep them that I don’t know about pleaseeee someone tell me.

One of the most boring games I have even played, it's way too repetitive, such a dissapointment.

Mafia III does a good number of things wrong. But I still had more fun playing it than GTA5.

Idk why but I enjoyed the missions and how simple they were so I didn’t mind that there were a ton of them I actually enjoyed grinding all the side missions. Try to stealth as much as I could then just go gorilla with the shotty on whoever was left . The setting did help bc New Orleans is my favorite city and maybe bc I was stoned outta my mind I just loved this game. That being said, I didn’t like Mafia 1 and never played 2 so do with that what you will

The Glitches even in 2024 make this game unplayable. Yes, LITERALLY UNPLAYABLE. I encountered a glitch where I was upgrading Sammy's Bar and the game cut to black. (supposedly because it was trying to start a mission but failed) I was stuck in an infinite black loading screen and so I quit the game and it spawned me back in, but every time it spawned me in I would fall under the map and would be unable to move. It practically broke the game where I lost all my progress permanently. Also, every so often the game would freeze for a few seconds and then resume.

Donovan isn't a psychopath, he is just used to dehumanizing and killing people as a war veteran, much like Lincoln. And they were both killing criminals and mercenaries, not civilians. As mentioned, he is carefree, derisive, and cynical. What was he supposed to do in the bar, for instance? Some guy was killed, no need to cry about it, or avoid taking his cigar. Overall, I don't think he was doing awful things and laughing it off (that would imply he was coping with unpleasant experiences through laughter). What made him dislikeable is the final scene in the church, where he was immature and extremely rude to father James, and desecrated the temple.

This video is criminally underrated!! Probably cause it's true. Huge props to author! Everything is made very well.

it's always nice to hear someone with a different opinion especially if it's betrayed in a thought out, entertaining way. I loved Mafia 3 but some of the points you made were good( I like stones unturned DLC but it was a bit too wacky and would have worked better as an extended Vietnam flashback)and this has me wanting to see more content from you

I loved the chapter system in the first two games, the structure of the story and horribly repetitive gameplay made this game feel so tedious

Dude I just finished watching all of your videos and I'm only just now noticing how many views and subscribers you have. Your level of quality is truly great, your jokes and references are hilarious and I got every single one. You really have a talent for making videos and I hope to see more from you at some point.

Definitive edition 1 still gives me hope they will return to the more linear format for 4. Hoping 2K shows something since the event is coming soon

I disagree. It is way too repetitive. That is for sure and ruins most of the game IMO. The story though is really really good and very satisfying to see through to the end. The characters are also awesome (especially Donovan). The gameplay isn't perfect but frankly I think the basic shooting combat is better than the rest of the series (including Mafia 1 remake). Maybe that's down to the guns being more modern but it also just feels more responsive to me than the rest. What does not get enough credit though is the driving. As a fan of simulation racing games, this has the best driving I have experienced outside of actual racing games. Especially when you get the faster cars in the game, IT IS SO MUCH FUN!!!!!!!!!!!!! The cars actually behave relatively realistically compared to most open world games like this. Hell, I've played many actual racing games that didn't have driving nearly as good as Mafia 3's

Trophies are glitched 🛑 I've been trying to obtain platinum for years now. 4 or more broken achievements due to the internal counter being broken/resetting upon closing/crashing the game. 2K GAMES don't care about their customers. I'm done after 11 playthroughs.

I thought mafia 3 was fantastic

The only thing mafia 3 will be rembered for is that kid that shit himself while streaming himself doing nothing important in the game.

I hope mafia 4 is any near to mafia 1 and 2 just have the vibe and bonding with characters to the story, not just killing change the chapters missions sometimes that’s what mafia 3 missed but like he says mafia 3 has only good Cutscenes and acting, many confuse with story and story is okay for me, vito was good addition but didn’t like the kill him option but I can see Tommy fans liking that and that is fair but it don’t fit after all vito has been through, with Joe I like he is alive but they didn’t address how and that is disappointment, I trust new leader Nick baynes he is making mafia 4 and it’s in early stages hopefully we get a trailer this year