Top 5 Overrated Games

We know the audio isn't great. But it's the best we can do - we are so busy running these shows at conventions, we aren't set up to record them live.

They might as well have turned Camilla’s mic off for her #1 she was booed so loudly

"We're all going to think of one word for Camilla's number 1 pick." ~ Joey 😆

There's so much booing during Camilla's number 1 that Youtube can't even figure out subtitles lol

Chris 5 Splendor 4 Great Western Trail 3 Quacks of Quedlinburg 2 Marvel United 1 Magic the Gathering Joey 5 Nemesis 4 Ark Nova 3 Zoo Vadis 2 Blood on the Clocktower 1 Gloomhaven Zee 5 Galaxy Truckers 4 Pulsar 2849 3 Tigris and Euphrates 2 Quacks of Quedlinburg 1 Nemesis Camilla 5 Deception Murder in Hong Kong 4 Eldritch Horror 3 Agricola 2 Wingspan 1 Just One Mike 5 Castles of Mad King Ludwig 4 Res Arcana 3 Betrayal at House on the HIll 2 Aeon's End 1 Great Western Trail Tom 5 Scrabble 4 Kingdom Builder 3 Betrayal at House on the Hill 2 The Mind 1 Mage Knight

Camilla being called out for calling Arkham Horror a euro game lol

Camilla's #1 nearly started a riot!

Gotta say… that might have been the best live top 5 you’ve ever done.

Perhaps recording from the sound mixer next time so it's more discernible.

Joey understood the assignment - he was on fire !🔥

Why is Mike not on a throne?

Thanks for posting this! Love seeing these panel discussions/top 10s even if I didn’t get to attend!

Tom's reaction to Camilla's #1 is so great.

One of these days I’m gonna make it to a Dice Tower convention. How can you not love this crew? Every time I watch them it’s like hanging out with good friends, even though I’ve never met any of them.

Good job pulling off a “family-friendly roast” vibe. Fun video. Specifically for solo, I don’t get the hype for Wingspan’s automa. It does not approximate how a human plays nor how a human would score (unless your friends regularly score 110-135 points). Maybe I keep getting unlucky, but it puts too many birds into play for the facedown bird card point value to effectively modulate the difficulty.

I turned on closed captions and it helped a bit. Great job to the team! Loved it! 😂

It had fun watching. It was funny and bold. Great job guys! 😊

Some of our favourite games are on your lists: 7th Continent, Mage Knights, Nemesis, Quacks, Ark Nova.....but we STILL LOVE THEM....😂. Great to see all of you together

People don't love Mage Knight because it's a deck builder or you move on a map Thom. It's because the combination of the deck building + hand management + board state = interesting, puzzle type gameplay that hasn't been successfully replicated to the same degree since it came out. I get why people might not like it, but the fact it's still a game that appears at the top of people's solo lists 13 years after it came out kind of says something. Edit: To elaborate on this. It would make more sense for Thom to point out other games that do what Mage Knight does, but better, in order to prove his point that it's overrated. Because it'll be hard for you to find any.

Will watch the video later but hope someone mention Earth. Most overrated nature game with poor production. Can’t get my head around being compared with Wingspan, Terraforming Mars and Ark Nova. Those 3 games had tons of different things to do, while in Earth the green cube, growth cube, the disposed card are all samey as they all give 1 points each. Not to mentioned the card power variety is super low.