Stardew Valley - All Luau Responses (Best Ingredients to Worst)

859,269
0
Published 2016-07-08
Every possible outcome for Pelican Town's summer festival, the Luau, where players are instructed to provide a high quality ingredient for the potluck soup for the Valley governor to sample. There are six possible outcomes - 'missing something' (no ingredient), best, good, neutral, bad, and worst.

Best outcome ingredients (from the Stardew Valley Wiki) [villager friendship bonus]:
Silver star: Crimsonfish, Ice Pip, Lava Eel, Legend, Starfruit
Gold star: Angler, Artichoke, Catfish, Cauliflower, Chanterelle, Cheese, Crimsonfish, Fairy Rose, Glacierfish, Goat Cheese, Ice Pip, Lava Eel, Legend, Melon, Mutant Carp, Purple Mushroom, Red Cabbage, Starfruit, Sturgeon, Super Cucumber, Truffle, Yam

Worst outcome ingredients [villager friendship loss]:
Any quality: Holly, Pufferfish, Red Mushroom, Sap, Scorpion Carp, Sea Cucumber

Bad outcome ingredients:
Any quality: Anchovy, Blackberry, Carp, Crocus, Daffodil, Green Algae, Herring, Joja Cola, Salmonberry, Seaweed, Spring Onion • Sunfish, Sweet Pea, White Algae

Good ingredients:
Normal quality: Amaranth, Angler, Apple, Artichoke, Beer, Beet, Cactus Fruit, Catfish, Cauliflower, Chanterelle, Cheese, Coffee, Cranberries, Crimsonfish, Crystal Fruit, Dorado, Energy Tonic, Fairy Rose, Glacierfish, Goat Cheese, Goat Milk, Ice Pip, Juice, Kale, Large Goat Milk, Large Milk, Largemouth Bass, Lava Eel, Legend, Lingcod, Maple Syrup, Melon, Milk, Morel, Muscle Remedy, Mutant Carp, Oil, Orange, Pale Ale, Peach, Pike, Pomegranate, Poppy, Purple Mushroom, Red Cabbage, Rice, Snow Yam, Starfruit, Strawberry, Sturgeon, Super Cucumber, Tiger Trout, Truffle, Truffle Oil, Tuna, Vinegar, Walleye, Wine, Yam

More info at: stardewvalleywiki.com/Luau

Thanks for watching!

If you've got some time to kill, have a sample of my Stardew Valley commentated playthrough... no pufferfish poison here ;)    • Stardew Valley Playthrough  

All Comments (21)
  • @Soulkey_sbr
    Mayor: This soup is disgusting. Does anyone want some? Everyone comes
  • @itsLalm
    funny how it all depends on you.
  • Lewis: hey um.. can you find and return my shorts? (Discreetly) Me: -drops shorts into soup
  • @SpeedyWeedyYT
    Me: puts void mayo in the soup Governor: vomits Lewis: good going guys! Thanks for ruining the festival. Me: yeah nice job guys!
  • @ivanm3045
    Adding that unprocessed pufferfish probably straight up killed the governor
  • @jrm48220
    They really try hard to guilt-trip you about not putting anything in.
  • @EChere
    Who knew one man/woman can change the entire soup taste.
  • Has anyone else played Harvest Moon DS? Apparently if you put a lvl 100 mushroom into the soup in that game it causes the credits to roll because everyone dies
  • @lukeburdon2930
    If you add nothing and they think something is missing must have been really boring before you come to town
  • @stardust5138
    I've put in a Red Mushroom in the soup for 76 years, and the Gov'na still looks forwards and eats the mush that's called a soup, and he's still alive.
  • Why do i need to lose friendship points? nobody knows who did it unless.....MARNIE!!! She told the mayor didn't she??
  • @Velraz
    Lewis be like : "Whoever put that foul ingredient in the soup made the Governor pass out! I'm ashamed. Well... does anyone want some ?"
  • i think it is funny that if you don't put anything in it is bland... does that mean after my grandfather died for the last XX years it has been bland? and how come he is still so excited for it after all those years
  • @Nekoszowa
    * adds pufferfish * "Lol, what a disaster."
  • @eggylove3338
    Marnie: Put something in the soup! Me: So wine? Marnie: Well maybe a vegetable or an e- Me: W I N E
  • @juliab7934
    My first year I didn’t know you were just supposed to bring one ingredient, I brought a salad...